Why I am Goth

August 8, 2008

Why am I Goth?  I’m not sure I even know I guess it just came about naturally which is strange considering my brother was the one that wore black a lot in high-school; people thought he was Goth.  But, no offense to him, I don’t think he ever really was.  Sure he wore black and had white face paint and black lipstick and no doubt that’s an aspect of Goth but that’s not what makes a person Goth.  No, Goth is more than that.  But first I want to clear up what it’s not – first of all IT’S NOT SATANISM!!!!!!  Goth isn’t even a religion; it’s more of a subculture than anything else.  It was born out of a music culture that was darker and harder than any other and it was born out of contempt for the value modern society placed on material objects.  It places emphasis on individuality and non-conformity and deep and honest thinking.  And sure like any other subculture it doesn’t always stay true to its values but what is a society (or subculture) without values to aspire to? 

 

Anyway I’ve strayed a bit off topic but me becoming Goth was something I sort of fell in to.  I guess you could say I’ve always been interested in a different perhaps one could say darker aesthetic I remember even putting on my brother’s black lipstick once when I was in middle school.  It was the first time I’d ever thought of myself as a beauty.  And I remember the very next second rubbing it off because I was afraid of trying to explain to my parents why I thought being dark would make me beautiful.  I was trying to be like all the popular girls and if I couldn’t do that I was content to be invisible.  And yet I look back and maybe it was something that was in me all along lurking in the shadows waiting to be acknowledged, waiting for me to come to peace with that piece of darkness; that beautiful piece of darkness.  It’s one of those strange things even though I call it a sort of darkness inside me it’s a part of the light of God; it exists happily with and in that light.  I kept that piece of me in the dark for a long time though.  All through middle school, high-school and part of college.  But strangely enough it was a casual comment from a roommate that brought that little piece of darkness into the light.  I don’t remember what sparked the comment I believe I was joking about ‘going’ Gothic and she said something like “You might as well, you wear enough black.”  She meant it as I joke and I took no offense but I was taken aback and I remember thinking something like “I don’t wear that much black.”  But I kept going back to that comment over the next week or so and thinking and trying to figure out why I wore so much black.  I began to think about what it meant to be Goth.  The first thing I did was buy a magazine called Gothic Beauty and found that much of the fashion in there was fantastic and breathtakingly beautiful.  If it weren’t for a rather unobtrusive ad in that magazine I might’ve never gone beyond that one magazine but I did.  That one ad was an ad for a conference for Christian Goths.  I was astounded.  I had never in my wildest dreams thought of such a thing as a Christian Goth.  But I was intrigued and so I turned to the one thing that my generation (and many others) looks to for information on anything and everything —- the internet.  I started with the website attached to the Gothic Christianity ad conveniently called www.GothicChristianity.com and from there I followed links to other Christian Goth websites one of which changed me for good.  It was called http://www.geocities.com/rvnshadowwinds/lair.html .  I spent several hours looking it all over and finding that with every word I read I felt more and more like I was reading thoughts that had been hanging around in my head for a long time just waiting to be vocalized and acknowledged.  It was freeing; like feeling a burst of cool breeze on a stifling humid summer day.  It felt like I could breathe for the first time in a long time. 

 

As I read Lady Raven’s explanations of what a Christian Goth is I felt a certain kinship; this woman could very well have read my thoughts so I will try to explain it as eloquently as she did.  Being Goth does not make you evil (OR A SATANIST) it doesn’t make you suicidal or homicidal.  Yes, Goth’s wear black but it’s just a color any meaning it might have is attached by that certain person; there is no inherent meaning in any color.  For me black is mysterious, classic, timeless, sleek and beautiful.  It’s neither evil nor good.  But if black were a person I imagine that he would scare a lot of people simply because he would be impossible to figure out or classify; there’d be no box to put him in — and that makes me smile.  Another aspect of Goth that makes people uncomfortable is the references to death.  This I don’t understand at all.  I see no reason to fear death it’s inevitable as much a part of life as being born.  Now before anyone accuses me of not being afraid of death because I’ve never experienced loss let me set you straight.  I lost my uncle to a heart attack when I was about 10.  I lost my grandmother to the death known as Alzheimer’s.  I lost my great-grandmother to old age.  I lost one classmate to a tragic accident.  I lost another classmate to a drunken driving accident.  And I lost a third classmate to another horrible disease.  And as trivial as it might seem to some; I lost my wonderful cat of ten years to a brain tumor (her picture can be viewed in my picture gallery).  I understand death.  But I don’t fear death.  And that is another part of the Goth subculture.  That is why there is a prevalence of skeletons and coffins; it is a way to remind people that the pursuit of material empty things is nothing in the end.  In death we are made equal. 

 

The supposition that in order to be Goth you have to be preoccupied with dying is erroneous and offensive.  It seems to me that the reason people ascribe an extreme suicidal bent to Goth’s more than any other subculture is because Goth’s are more willing to admit death is real plus it protects the accuser from having to admit that being depressed happens to everybody whether rich or poor, beautiful or strange-looking, man or woman, adult or child.  This leads me to another reason I became Goth.  I no longer had to be afraid of feeling.  I had felt such pressure from society and church to be happy and content all the time that when I wasn’t I assumed it meant there was something wrong; being Goth meant I could acknowledge those other feelings, I could feel those other feelings and it was OK.  It was ok to be human. 

 

I don’t know how well I’ve explained myself or if it even makes sense what I’m saying but I hope it might offer some insight into what this particular Goth thinks Goth is.  No doubt you will hear and experience differing views and opinions on what Goth is; some positive and some not so positive but I hope you will keep an open mind and remember that getting to know someone and seeing what’s inside is more important than making snap judgments based on what they’re wearing.

 

 

Just thought I’d share this with you guys since I’ve been asked by a few people what drew me to the Goth subculture; like I said I’m not sure how well I’ve explained myself but let me know if you have any other questions, I’d be happy to try and answer.

9 Responses to “Why I am Goth”

  1. Michelle said

    Thank you for this. When I first asked, you sent me to Raven’s site. I find her intriguing.

    Getting to know the person on the inside is what it’s all about. My hairdresser is Goth. She’s been in my life for a few years now, we graduated from the same highschool. The other day when I was there we were talking about my daughter’s choice of black. At the time I was wearing a bright red shirt with black capri’s and patent leather red flipflops with black toenail polish. She looked me up and down and started talking to me about the meaning of colors. “They say those who wear lots of black like to be invisible. Those that wear bright colors with black are trying to say I’m quite shocking on the inside, but I might not always show it.”

    She had me pegged.

    I have an amazing poem about the color black if you want to hear it. I didn’t write it but it’s from a book of poetry about colors, Hailstones and Halibut Bones. My favorite book of poetry.

    Hope you’re settled now. ;)

  2. Michelle;
    I agree, Lady Raven is intriguing.

    Anyway about your hairdresser’s observations about people who wear black…yeah I can see it; the whole trying to blend in with the dark of night type of thing.

    My reason for wearing black, though, (if you don’t mind me sharing) is to be more visible instead of less. I’ve spent so long it seems hiding behind something or someone and feeling as though people looked through me instead of at me that when I wear black it’s like a challenge. I’m challenging people to try and ignore the “Goth Girl” with her black fingernails, fingerless gloves and slightly victorian-style clothing. *Shrugs.*

    Yeah so… and her observation about the whole bright colors with black thing is interesting. :) Yeah, I like it.

    I would love to hear the poem anytime you want just shoot me an e-mail or post it on a comment…whichever. And I’m getting settled, I don’t think I’ll feel truly settled until school starts back up (September 2nd) and I get back into the swing of things. woohoo!

    G

  3. Crystal said

    You have really made my day. Reading this has finally brought me a sense of clarity. I just became goth just a few days ago. I felt the same way you felt. Like this part of me has always been there. That when I was asked why I was always down and depressed looking (especially at church)that there was something wrong. People at my school constantly keep asking me questions like “Are you punk? or Are you a rocker chick?”At first Id ignore them. I wanted to be modest about it. Someone will ask me am I goth and depending on if Im still in the class with them and how much longer we have till next class, I may or may not had answered. Id critically think it over and Id nod my head yes and look back down at my work.

    I could go on and on about my first week as a goth but you really took a wait off my shoulder. I knew I wasnt the only one that felt this way.

  4. Crystal said

    Correction:

    ‘weight’ off my shoulder

    >.<

  5. Crystal,
    Hey! I am always glad to help and really I’m glad this little biographical essay of mine could help you. And don’t worry there are more of us out there, I’ve got websites (other than the two mentioned in the essay) that if you want I can direct you too. Anyway just wanted to say: stay strong and I’m glad to have made a new friend :)
    Peace,
    G

  6. Lily said

    “born out of contempt for the value modern society placed on material objects.”

    and yet you say it was makeup, clothing and magazines that first helped you realise you were falling into gothic culture? It really sounds just as materialistic as any other subculture to me.

    ” I don’t fear death. And that is another part of the Goth subculture. That is why there is a prevalence of skeletons and coffins; it is a way to remind people that the pursuit of material empty things is nothing in the end. ”

    You know, Buddists don’t fear death either? Nor do they morn the dead. In fact- they retain no attatchment to the physical world at all. If you truely want to meet someone who understands and accepts the circle of life then I suggest you visit a temple.

    I can honestly not see how owning skeleton and coffin parafanalia is any less materialistic than owning any other kind; how buying Victorian style clothing is any different to buying any other style; how black coloured lipstick is anything less of a material asset that any other shade.I really did like your comment ‘in death we are made equal’. I feel this is very true.

    ” It places emphasis on individuality and non-conformity ”

    “Being Goth meant I could acknowledge those other feelings, I could feel those other feelings and it was OK. It was ok to be human.”

    I don’t mean this as a personal attack at all- I could be saying it about any other subculure in existance.
    The thing about subcultures is that as you mentioned they are full of ideals and images. There is no room for non-conformity when you are willing to classify yourself under such a generic term with so many implications behind it.

    I’m glad you are content the way you are but I find it actually depressing that only by labelling yourself and dressing in a certain way could you feel human and at easy with your emotions.
    Be your own person… enough of the labels.

  7. Lily,
    First off let me say that I don’t view what you’ve said as a personal attack, but I would like to address a few things you said –

    First off, I don’t believe I ever said that the Goth subculture wasn’t materialistic. It is However it does not place the same emphasis on pursuing material goods (i.e. wealth, fame, etc) as the mainstream population does. But more than that (and this I didn’t get across too well) the Goth subculture is built around the music.

    Again with your second part of your comment we are back to the materialistic. I didn’t say Goth’s weren’t materialistic just that they didn’t place a large emphasis on it. But the clothes and makeup do tend to play a big part of the Goth subculture. And as far as the coffins, skeletons and crosses the only reason I mentioned this is because I hear people saying that they think its wierd why someone would wear skeletons (and crosses and…yeah you get the idea) because it’s so “depressing” – and I wanted to offer up my opinion of why Goth’s would continue that behavior.

    As far as the last part of your comment. I see nothing wrong with your reasoning, in fact I think I even agree. But this is me and no matter what label I might choose to give myself I still won’t fit into a box no matter how hard someone might want to try to put me there.

    Just so you know your last line made me smile. Indeed “be your own person.” Hope this is satisfactory. And I look forward to any other comments you might have. :)

    G

  8. StrayCatDebbs said

    Thank you for that…….
    Reading it, I finally felt proud to be, as you – A Christian Goth.
    I didn’t even know there were others, quite a crowd, actually who discibed themselves thus. I’m glad I’m not alone and glad I googled those two words on a whim.
    I’ve actually had gothic leanings most of my life, But I stiffled them, thinking them sinful because of sidelong stares and quickly averted eyes when ever I showed ‘too much’ interest and enthusiam for such things.
    I find myself smiling when I read of how you kept getting questions on why you wore so much black and if you were goth in high school (before you….’came out’ as one)
    I had the same experiences. I remember a few girls in my youth group asking why I wore so much black (this was news to me. I hadn’t even really noticed) and then enthusiasticly encouraging me everytime I wore another color. It was rather cute, actually and done out of kindness, but stiffling, none the less
    It wasn’t just that, of course. It was all these little things about my personality, behaviour and preferances that all added up.
    But, it’s only in my early to mid twenties that I’ve ceased to see it as bad thing. It’s been a very gradual change and a series of revelations, big and small.
    Thank you for allowing me to share this.
    It is a weight off my chest.

  9. Deb,
    You are the third person to thank me and the second to say that I helped clarify things for you and I wanted to say “you’re welcome.” I am incredibly humbled by how much this little essay has helped (you and Crystal and anyone else who read it and got clarification). So along with my “you’re welcome” I also wanted to say “Thank you” and I’m glad to have met you. :)
    G

Leave a Reply